Does HRV go up when I get fitter, and how fast?

Getting fitter tends to raise resting HRV, but less than people hope. Pooled training studies show a moderate rise in high-frequency HRV and a larger slowing of the heart, with a smaller response in older people. Fitter people have higher vagal HRV at any training load, and very fit athletes can hit a ceiling where HRV stops rising or even falls as the heart slows further.

On this page 6 sections

Key takeaways

  • In 13 training studies with 322 people, exercise raised high-frequency HRV by a moderate effect size (d = 0.48) and lengthened the RR interval by more (d = 0.75).
  • The RR interval response to training was smaller in older participants, and the HRV response showed the same trend.
  • In 55 adults, vagal HRV tracked fitness (VO2max) rather than weekly training load; heart rate recovery did the reverse.
  • In world-champion rowers, HRV fell alongside the HRV-to-RR ratio during heavy training, a sign of parasympathetic saturation, not of lost fitness.
  • Expect a slow, modest rise over months of regular endurance training, and a plateau once you are very fit.

Usually, and modestly. Pooling 13 training studies with 322 people, Sandercock, Bromley and Brodie (2005) found that exercise training raised high-frequency HRV, a vagal measure, by a moderate effect size (d = 0.48) and lengthened the resting RR interval RR interval The time from one heartbeat to the next, measured in milliseconds between the R peaks of an ECG. HRV is calculated from a series of these intervals. More about RR interval by more (d = 0.75). The heart slows more reliably than HRV rises, the response is smaller after 60, and very fit athletes can reach a ceiling.

What training studies show

The 2005 meta-analysis is still the clearest summary. Across 13 studies of high-frequency power HF power The variance of the heartbeat intervals that falls in the 0.15 to 0.40 Hz band, in ms²: the range of normal breathing. It mainly reflects vagal activity when breathing is 9 to 24 breaths a minute. More about HF power (322 participants) the pooled effect was d = 0.48 (95% CI 0.26 to 0.70); across 12 studies of the RR interval (298 participants) it was d = 0.75 (0.51 to 0.96). A moderate effect of this size means a typical participant moved from the middle of the untrained group to around its 70th percentile, with plenty of overlap. Subgroup analysis found a smaller RR interval response in older participants (at the authors’ P < 0.1 threshold), and the HRV response showed the same trend. The authors suggest that training slows the heart through more than one mechanism, not only more vagal activity Vagal tone The ongoing influence of the vagus nerve on the heart, which slows it down. It is usually estimated from HRV measures such as RMSSD and HF power. More about Vagal tone , which is one reason the two measures do not move together.

For older adults, Raffin and colleagues (2019) found that endurance training raised SDNN SDNN The standard deviation of all NN intervals in a recording, in milliseconds. It measures overall variability, and its value depends strongly on how long the recording lasts. More about SDNN in people around 69, with gains that grew with sessions per week; can HRV improve after 60 has the numbers. A review by Grässler and colleagues (2021) found that endurance, coordination and mixed programmes improved autonomic control in older adults, while resistance training alone did not.

Fitness or training load?

Buchheit and Gindre (2006) separated the two in 55 adults of around 31 years. Vagal HRV at rest correlated with fitness (peak oxygen uptake, VO2max) but not with how much the person trained each week; heart rate recovery after exercise did the opposite, tracking training load but not fitness. The fit groups had higher vagal HRV than the unfit groups whatever their training; the moderately trained groups differed from the low-trained groups in heart rate recovery whatever their fitness. So resting HRV reflects the fitness you have built more than the week you have just done, which is why it moves slowly.

How fast

The studies do not give a clean number of weeks. The pooled training programmes ran for months, and the authors of the older-adult meta-analysis found that frequency, not just duration, drove the gain. A fair expectation is a slow rise over a few months of regular endurance training, with resting heart rate Resting heart rate How many times your heart beats per minute while you are fully at rest. For adults it is usually 60 to 100 beats per minute, and lower in well-trained athletes. More about Resting heart rate often moving first, and wide differences between people: is HRV genetic explains why two people on the same programme can differ.

The ceiling in very fit people

In endurance athletes HRV can stop rising, or fall, as the heart slows further. Plews and colleagues (2017) followed four world-champion rowers day by day and saw consistent, substantial falls in the ratio of log RMSSD lnRMSSD The natural logarithm of RMSSD, with no unit. Taking the log evens out the spread of RMSSD values, which makes day-to-day changes easier to compare and analyse. More about lnRMSSD to the RR interval during heavy training. They write that reductions in log RMSSD that come together with reductions in this ratio indicate parasympathetic saturation Parasympathetic saturation When the vagal brake is so strong, usually in very fit people with very slow resting heart rates, that the beat-to-beat swing shrinks. HRV then falls while vagal activity is rising. More about Parasympathetic saturation : the vagal brake is already fully on, so the usual beat-to-beat swing shrinks even though the athlete is coping. A fall in HRV in a very fit person therefore does not always mean lost fitness or fatigue. Reading HRV next to resting heart rate is the practical check; HRV vs resting heart rate shows how, and can HRV detect overtraining covers the opposite case.

What to do with your own data

  1. Track resting heart rate and HRV together over months. The heart rate trend usually shows training effects first.
  2. Judge the 7-day average, not single days. The baseline lesson shows how.
  3. Prefer regular endurance sessions if raising HRV is the goal; the training page covers session types.
  4. If you are already very fit and HRV drifts down while you feel strong and your heart rate is low, consider saturation before fatigue.

When to talk to a doctor

HRV cannot measure fitness or diagnose overtraining. Talk to a doctor if training brings chest pain, fainting, breathlessness out of proportion to the effort, or a racing or irregular heartbeat.

Common questions

I have trained for eight weeks and my HRV has not moved. Is something wrong?

Not necessarily. The pooled studies show a moderate average change, with wide individual spread, and resting heart rate often moves before HRV does. Check your resting heart rate trend and give it months, not weeks.

Can HRV go down as I get fitter?

In very fit endurance athletes, yes. As the heart slows, HRV can stop rising or fall, a pattern called parasympathetic saturation. The ratio of HRV to the RR interval helps tell this from fatigue.

Does strength training raise HRV?

The evidence is weaker than for endurance training. A review in older adults found resistance training alone did not improve cardiac autonomic control, while endurance and mixed programmes did.

Sources

  1. Effects of exercise on heart rate variability: inferences from meta-analysis Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2005
  2. Cardiac parasympathetic regulation: respective associations with cardiorespiratory fitness and training load American Journal of Physiology-Heart and Circulatory Physiology, 2006
  3. Day-to-Day Heart-Rate Variability Recordings in World-Champion Rowers: Appreciating Unique Athlete Characteristics International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 2017
  4. Exercise Frequency Determines Heart Rate Variability Gains in Older People: A Meta-Analysis and Meta-Regression Sports Medicine, 2019
  5. Effects of different exercise interventions on heart rate variability and cardiovascular health factors in older adults: a systematic review European Review of Aging and Physical Activity, 2021