Stationarity

Also called stationary, nonstationarity, non-stationary

The assumption that the rhythms in a recording stay the same from start to finish. Frequency measures such as LF and HF need it; a recording that changes partway through breaks it.

A spectrum describes a recording as a mix of steady waves: so much power at the breathing rhythm, so much at the 10-second blood-pressure rhythm, and so on. That description only makes sense if the mix stays the same for the whole recording. Statisticians call such a series stationary.

Real recordings break the rule easily. Standing up halfway, starting to talk, a cough, or falling asleep changes heart rate and its rhythms, and the spectrum then averages two different states into one that never existed. The 1996 Task Force standards ask for short-term recordings made under stable conditions for this reason.

Why it matters for HRV.

  • Keep conditions fixed. Laborde, Mosley and Thayer (2017) ask for no movement during a recording and a settled posture before it starts. That is what keeps a 5-minute reading stationary.
  • Split, do not smooth. Detrending Detrending Removing the slow drift from a series of beat intervals before a spectrum is calculated, so the drift does not pile up as false power in the lowest frequencies. More about Detrending removes a slow drift, but it cannot fix a sudden change. The diagram below shows a step of 90 ms halfway through a recording: detrending removes most of it but leaves a jolt where the change happened, which the spectrum then counts as rhythm. The fix is to analyse the two halves separately.
  • Do not compare lengths. A longer recording takes in more change, so its measures are not comparable with a short one’s.

A step the spectrum cannot handle

The teaching recording, altered

Top: the teaching recording with a change of posture halfway through, so the second half runs 90 ms shorter. A spectrum assumes the rhythms stay the same from start to finish; this step breaks that assumption. Bottom: detrending removes most of the step but leaves a jolt where it happened, and that jolt is not part of any steady rhythm. The fix is to analyse the two halves separately.

Two line charts of the gap between beats over five minutes. The top one drops by about 90 ms halfway through and stays lower; the bottom one is level again around zero, with a short jolt where the step was and the breathing wave on top.

See also detrending and how to take a good HRV reading.

Sources

  1. Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use Circulation (Task Force of the ESC and NASPE), 1996
  2. Heart rate variability and cardiac vagal tone in psychophysiological research: recommendations for experiment planning, data analysis, and data reporting Frontiers in Psychology, 2017

All glossary terms